Except #GamerGate has had real-life impacts on the lives and careers of actual people, mainly women. The next time anyone at any college sits around wondering why it is that they can't get more girls interested in majoring in computer sciences, point them towards this issue. Why would they want to, if it meant risking this kind of treatment?
|Katherine Cross's tweets, on women in the gaming industry leaving|
It's not just a problem with gamer culture though, it's a larger problem with, I believe, geek culture. And it's not just a problem with misogyny (though that is a huge part of it). It's a problem of entitlement.
In so many of the pieces I've read about this controversy I see an angry group of people who want desperately to be taken seriously. And that's been true of the gaming medium for years. Many gamers wanted their hobby to be something more than the thing they did that was a waste of time, that was pure consumerism and entertainment and that parents and educators believed was worthless. Games were art, it was argued. And I agree: they are art. And the larger culture in recent years has accepted them as such. Games have now been included in the Smithsonian. Games have invaded how we create theater. Games are now part of advertising. Scholars write and speak about how games can actually improve the world around us.
|Someone told me this guy's famous.|
Guess what guys. You can't have it both ways. You can't expect the world to take you seriously and not at the same time subject you to cultural criticism. Filmmakers can't make movies without feminist scrutiny, favorite TV artists are criticized all the time. The growing awareness of how women have long been represented in media and art has led to us taking a hard look at rape culture and its effects. And games are a part of that. That is what you wanted when you asked to be taken seriously.
So games are now art - a viewpoint with which I wholeheartedly agree. Add onto that the fact that games now have a much wider, more diverse audience. Add onto that serious discussions about entitlement, rape, racism, queer issues, and the fact that people of different demographics want to be portrayed as diversely as white men have been for years.
You are not entitled to a seat at the big boy table of cultural discussion while simultaneously being allowed to not evolve with culture. No one is. The discussion is happening everywhere, not just in your niche. And by and large, in other mediums, when pieces of art are criticized on social issues the reaction is...wait for it...discussion. DISCUSSION. Not threats, not harassing, not huge online manifestos, not delusions of being qualified to "peer review" academic journal articles based on having played games lots (FYI - I have a terminal degree in my field, and I don't know if *I* am qualified to peer review something IN MY FIELD). I'm not saying that ridiculous sexism and misogyny doesn't occur in other media - it certainly does. Ask Jennifer Lawrence. But to take part in this, and to be taken seriously, you have to participate in civil discussion. You have to consider the other side. And until that happens, your movement is NOT going to be taken seriously. People outside of gaming culture will continue to laugh, continue to scratch their heads and wonder how the hell this got to be so "important," and people will CONTINUE to side with those who have been undeservedly harmed by members of your movement. You have to respond respectfully.
Just as the showrunners for Game of Thrones have to.
Just as every regional theater that produces seasons of largely white male playwrights has to.
|The Guthrie: All White Men, All The Time.|
Just as Christians have to.
Just as FEMINISTS have to.
Just as any sub-culture, any group, has to deal with the fact that some of its loudest voices are the least attractive.
And you might want to consider not only distancing yourselves from the hashtag #GamerGate but outright rejecting it, and starting over. #GamerGate started with attempts to destroy the lives of two women. You can't recover from that, and claim that your movement is about ethics. You just can't. No one will take you seriously. You are not entitled to that.